The image below is taken from Diary No 7, (23 April-24 June 1784). Hamilton socialised with many well known figures of her day including Samuel Johnson. The diary entry for 14th May 1784 describes a dinner that they both attended and it demonstrates what rich a resource Hamilton’s writings offer for the study of prominent figures in society during the late eighteenth century.
At a dinner with guests that included Eva Maria Garrick, Frances Burney, Hannah More and Elizabeth Carter, Hamilton recorded Samuel Johnson’s unflattering description and characterisation of the author Oliver Goldsmith.
Hamilton writes that Johnson (she spells his name ‘Johnston’ in her diary) noted that he ‘never knew a Head so unfurnished [as Goldsmith’s]; he gave him credit for being a Clerical Scholar so far as he had learnt at school, but that he knew very little of any subject he ever wrote upon…upon the most common subjects he was most ignorant, of which he gave many and daily proofs; he had the habit of lying to such a degree that the Club to which he belonged and the society he lived in never scrupled to tell him they wanted Faith for what he advanced. [He continued noting that he] was the most envious of Men; he could not bear to hear the praise of any one, nay! even the Beauty of a woman being praised he could not endure’.
According to the diary, Johnson did note that Goldsmith had many ‘good qualities’ before listing his ‘many failings’. Of his book on the History of England, Johnson noted that Goldsmith ‘knew nothing more of it than turning over two or 3 English Historians & abridging them’.
This description of Goldsmith covers four pages of the diary and also includes Elizabeth Carter’s view of him and a story by Mrs Garrick of Goldsmith being often at her house when her husband, [the actor, David Garrick] was alive and that he was never ‘happy if he did not gain the attention of the Whole Company to himself’.
Lisa Crawley.

Diary entry for 14th May 1784